My Perfect Mortgage
Should You Stay or Should You Go? Navigating Your Mortgage Refinance with the Same Lender vs. a New Lender
4 minute read
June 10, 2024

Refinancing your mortgage can be a strategic financial move to save money on your monthly payments, consolidate debt, or access cash from your home's equity.

But when it comes to choosing a lender, a common question arises: should you stick with your current mortgage lender or explore options with new lenders? 

This article dives into the pros and cons of both approaches to help you make an informed decision.

  • available in AL, CA, CO, CT, FL, GA, IL, MA, MD, MI, MN, NC, NJ, NY, OH, PA, SC, TX, VA, WA
  • Simple application
  • Quick decisions
  • Common sense underwriting
  • Fast closing period
  • Lend in all 50 states
  • Veteran lending specialist available to you, no matter where you are
  • In-house processing and underwriting
  • Express Loan Approval program, which allows you to be done with the whole process (minus the contract and appraisal), so you can focus on finding your home.
  • Rate Protect (Lock & Shop) lock in your rate before you even find a home!

Refinancing with Your Current Lender

There's a certain comfort in staying with a familiar face. Refinancing with your current mortgage lender offers some potential advantages:

  • Convenience: Your current lender likely has your financial information readily available, streamlining the application process. This can save you time and effort in gathering documents like pay stubs, tax returns, and bank statements.
  • Lower Fees: Knowing your history as a customer, your current lender might be willing to waive some closing costs or offer lower origination fees to retain your business. This can translate to significant cost savings upfront.
  • Faster Processing: Since your lender already has your financial information, the application review and approval process could be faster than a new lender who needs to start from scratch.

Exploring Refinance Options with New Lenders

While convenience has its merits, it shouldn't overshadow potentially better deals available elsewhere. Here's why exploring new lenders for your refinance can be advantageous:

  • Potentially Lower Rates: Competition in the mortgage lending market is fierce. By shopping around and comparing quotes from multiple lenders, you have a higher chance of securing a more competitive interest rate. Even a slight difference in the interest rate can translate to significant savings over the life of your loan.
  • Wider Range of Options: Different lenders offer a variety of loan products and terms. You might find a new lender with a specific loan program that better suits your needs, such as a shorter loan term or a cash-out refinance option if you need to access home equity.
  • Negotiation Leverage: Knowing you're considering other lenders empowers you to negotiate with your current lender. Once you have quotes with better rates or terms, you can use them as leverage to get a more competitive offer from your current lender potentially.

Weighing the Options: A Checklist for Choosing the Right Lender

Knowing the pros and cons of each approach is just the first step.

Here's a checklist to guide you in choosing the right lender for your refinance:

  • Get quotes from multiple lenders: Aim to get quotes from at least 3-5 lenders, including your current mortgage holder. This ensures you have a good comparison point for rates, fees, and loan terms.
  • Compare interest rates and APR (Annual Percentage Rate): Focus on the APR, which takes into account the interest rate and certain closing costs, to get a more accurate picture of the overall loan cost. A lower APR generally translates to a more affordable loan.
  • Consider loan terms: Beyond the interest rate, consider factors like the loan term (length of the loan), prepayment penalties (if any), and any points associated with the loan (an upfront fee that can lower your interest rate).
  • Evaluate fees: Carefully compare closing costs associated with each lender's offer. These can include origination fees, appraisal fees, title insurance fees, and recording fees.
  • Customer service: Consider the lender's reputation for customer service. Research online reviews and ask about communication channels and responsiveness to inquiries.
  • Online tools and resources: Some lenders offer online tools and resources that can streamline the application process and make communication easier.

Building Trust with Your Lender

Refinancing involves sharing sensitive financial information, and building trust with your new or existing lender is crucial.

The following are tips to ensure a smooth transition with your lender.

  • Ask questions: Don't hesitate to ask questions about the loan terms, fees, and any aspects of the refinance process you need help understanding. A good lender will be transparent and patient in explaining everything.
  • Read the fine print: Before signing any loan documents, thoroughly review the terms and conditions. Make sure you understand all the details of the loan before committing.
  • Maintain clear communication: Keep your lender informed of any changes in your financial situation throughout the application process. This helps ensure a smooth and efficient process.

The Bottom Line: Don't Settle for Convenience; Prioritize Value

While refinancing with your current lender offers some convenience, keep familiarity from clouding your judgment. The potential for a more competitive interest rate and wider loan options found with new lenders can outweigh the ease of staying with your current one.

By following these tips, taking the time to compare offers, and prioritizing value over convenience, you can navigate the mortgage refinance process with confidence.

Our advise is based on experience in the mortgage industry and we are dedicated to helping you achieve your goal of owning a home. We may receive compensation from partner banks when you view mortgage rates listed on our website.