Conventional vs VA Loans: Which is better?

If you’re exploring the goal of homeownership, one of the first things you’ll need to consider is the type of loan to apply for. Conventional vs VA loans, DSCR loans vs UDSA loans, FHA loans… the list may seem endless and confusing.

With this array of options available, it’s essential to understand the nuances between them, especially when comparing conventional loans vs VA loans.

This understanding will not only guide you toward making an informed decision but also help you select a loan that best aligns with your financial circumstances and goals.

What is meant by a ‘conventional loan’

Conventional loans are the most common type of mortgage—not guaranteed by any government agency.

They are ideal for borrowers with:

Strong credit
A stable income
The ability to make a down payment

Down payments for conventional loans

One of the hallmark requirements of a conventional loan is the down payment, which typically ranges from the higher end of 20% to a low of 3% of the home’s purchase price.

The exact down payment amount depends on the borrower’s creditworthiness and the loan terms.

Furthermore, if your down payment is less than 20%, you’ll likely need to pay for private mortgage insurance (PMI) which also increases the monthly mortgage payment.

How to Cancel Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) on a Conventional Loan

Canceling private mortgage insurance (PMI) can lead to significant savings for homeowners. Here’s a step-by-step guide to understanding and navigating the process.

Building Required Equity

Equity Milestone: PMI is typically required until you build enough equity in your home. Your lender will automatically terminate PMI when your mortgage balance equals 78% of your home’s original purchase price or its appraised value at purchase.
Midway Cancellation: Even if the balance hasn’t reached the 78% mark, PMI must be canceled at the halfway point of the loan term. For example, on a 30-year mortgage, this would be after 15 years.

Requesting Early Cancellation

Reach 80% Loan-to-Value Ratio: If you want to cancel PMI before automatic conditions are met, you can request cancellation once your mortgage balance is 80% of the home’s original value. This can often be achieved by making extra payments or benefiting from property value appreciation.
Verify Home Value: To strengthen your request, you may need an official appraisal to prove that your home has sufficient equity.

Communicating with Your Lender

Contact your Mortgage Servicer: Write to your mortgage service provider for PMI cancellation. Be prepared to present proof of your equity and possibly cover the cost of a new appraisal.
Check for Further Requirements: Some lenders may require even more conditions, such as a history of timely payments, before they approve the cancellation.

By following these steps, you can eliminate unnecessary PMI costs, potentially saving thousands over the life of your mortgage.

What are VA Loans?

Conversely, VA loans offer a powerful homebuying option for veterans, active military members, and select military spouses.

The Department of Veterans Affairs backs these loans—designed to make homeownership more accessible to those who have served our country.

No down payment requirement for VA loans

Topping the list of significant advantages of VA loans is the possibility of a zero-down payment purchase.

This feature makes it much easier for qualified borrowers to purchase a home without waiting years to save for a down payment.

No PMI

Additionally, VA loans do not require PMI, regardless of the down payment amount, which can substantially lower monthly payments compared to conventional loans.

Eligibility for a VA loan is based on service duration and duty status, with specific requirements outlined by the VA, including:

Serving for a minimum number of days in active duty during wartime or peacetime
Having a spouse who died in the line of duty / as a result of a service-related disability

What options are available for financing the VA funding fee?

When it comes to the VA funding fee, you have a couple of flexible options for covering it:

Pay in Cash at Closing: If you prefer not to include it in your long-term mortgage payments, you can choose to pay the VA funding fee upfront in full with cash during the closing process. This option might save you money in interest over the life of the loan.
Finance the Fee as Part of Your Loan: Alternatively, you can choose to roll the VA funding fee into the total amount of your mortgage. This means you’ll spread out the cost across the lifetime of your loan, making it easier to manage if upfront costs are a concern.

Each of these choices allows you to find the best fit for your financial situation, so consider both options carefully based on your current and future budget plans.

VA Funding Fee Exemptions: Who Qualifies?

When considering a VA loan, understanding potential exemptions from the VA funding fee is crucial. Here are the key groups who bypass this fee:

Purple Heart Recipients: Active-duty service members who have received a Purple Heart are fully exempt.
Veterans with Service-Connected Disabilities: Those receiving compensation for disabilities incurred or aggravated in the line of duty qualify for the exemption.
Surviving Spouses: If they receive Dependency and Indemnity Compensation due to their spouse’s service-related death, they are exempt from the fee.

These categories help ease the financial burden on eligible applicants, ensuring they can efficiently access veterans’ benefits.

Key differences between VA loans vs conventional loans

Side by side, the primary differences between these two loan types become immediately apparent, namely:

Down payment requirements
Interest rates
Eligibility criteria
The need for insurance

Why a VA Loan Could Be Ideal for Those with a Higher Debt-to-Income Ratio

For individuals navigating financial constraints, particularly those with a higher debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, a VA loan can present a compelling choice. Here’s why:

Minimal Down Payment Requirements: Unlike conventional loans that typically mandate a substantial down payment, VA loans often require little to no upfront payment. This alleviates the initial financial burden and makes homeownership more accessible to those juggling debts.
Absence of Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI): While most traditional loans demand ongoing PMI payments if the down payment is below 20%, VA loans do not. This exemption significantly reduces monthly costs, offering more breathing room in your budget.
One-time Funding Fee: Although there is a VA funding fee associated with these loans, it’s a one-off cost. In contrast, other loan structures could incur recurring insurance fees, which can add up over time. The funding fee may even be rolled into the loan amount, minimizing upfront expenses.

By choosing a VA loan, borrowers with higher DTIs can more effectively manage their finances without the recurring pressure of additional insurance costs. This allows for a more streamlined path to securing a home.

Understanding Debt-to-Income Ratio Requirements for VA and Conventional Loans

When you’re exploring mortgage options, it’s crucial to understand how debt-to-income (DTI) ratios affect your eligibility. Let’s break down how these requirements differ between VA loans and conventional loans.

What is a Debt-to-Income Ratio?

Your debt-to-income ratio is a key financial metric. It measures the percentage of your monthly gross income that is dedicated to paying off debts, including your mortgage. A lower DTI generally indicates to lenders that you are less risky, which might help you secure better mortgage terms.

VA Loans: A Flexible Approach

VA loans, backed by the Department of Veterans Affairs, offer significant flexibility regarding DTI ratios. While the VA itself does not set a maximum DTI, lenders typically start a more detailed review if your DTI surpasses 41%. Interestingly, recent data from ICE Mortgage Technology reveals that borrowers who secured VA loans in the last 30 days had an average DTI of around 44%. This suggests that VA loans might afford more leeway in approving applicants with higher DTIs compared to other loan types.

Conventional Loans: Stricter Guidelines

Conventional loans, which are not insured by government entities, tend to have stricter DTI requirements. Lenders generally prefer a DTI of less than 36%, although exceptions can be made if other factors are favorable, like a high credit score or sizable down payment. The average DTI for recent successful applicants is approximately 37%, according to ICE Mortgage Technology, indicating the tighter constraints these loans typically entail.

Choose the Right Loan for Your DTI

In summary, if your DTI is above 36%, you may find it easier to qualify for a VA loan than a conventional one. This is particularly true if your DTI is closer to or exceeds the 41% mark. Regardless of the loan type you’re considering, reducing your debt can improve your DTI and enhance your chances of securing a mortgage with favorable rates.

Understanding Credit Score Requirements for VA and Conventional Loans

When considering either a VA loan or a conventional loan, your credit score plays a crucial role in the loan terms you can obtain. Here’s a breakdown of how these two types of loans handle credit score requirements.

VA Loan Credit Score Requirements

The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) doesn’t set a strict credit score threshold. However, individual lenders typically have their own criteria. Most lenders require a credit score between 580 and 620 for VA loans. Interestingly, recent data indicates that borrowers who successfully secured VA purchase loans had an average credit score of 725. This suggests that while lower scores might technically qualify, higher scores are more common among approved applicants.

Conventional Loan Credit Score Standards

In contrast, conventional loans, which aren’t backed by the federal government, usually require a minimum credit score of 620. This requisite can vary, as different lenders may have their own standards. According to recent data, the average credit score for successful conventional loan applicants stands at 753, indicating that higher scores are advantageous and commonplace among these borrowers.

Key Takeaways

Easier Qualification for Lower Scores: If your credit score is below 620, you might find it easier to qualify for a VA loan as opposed to a conventional loan.
Alternative Options: For those not eligible for a VA loan, FHA loans offer another route. They require a minimum credit score of 500 with a 10% down payment, or 580 with a 3.5% down payment, providing flexibility for different financial situations.

Understanding these credit score benchmarks can help you assess which loan option aligns best with your financial standing.

Advantages of VA loans

VA loans offer unparalleled benefits for veterans and active-duty service members, a testament to the nation’s gratitude for their service.

VA loans do not require a down payment
Borrowers are exempt from private mortgage insurance (PMI)
Reduced monthly payments due to lack of PMI
More competitive interest rates
Limit on closing costs

Advantages of conventional loans

“Despite the appealing benefits of VA loans, conventional loans might be more advantageous in certain scenarios. Some examples include:

Investors looking to purchase rental properties
Individuals buying a second home
Buyers who have not served or are not married to someone who has served in the military

For goals like these, conventional loans are often more suitable since VA loans are strictly for primary residences, and for those who have served or are currently serving in the military. Moreover, borrowers who can afford a sizeable down payment might prefer a conventional loan to avoid the VA funding fee and capitalize on the equity in their home from the outset.

If you can put down 20% on a conventional loan, you can skip mortgage insurance, which can significantly reduce overall costs compared to a VA loan. This makes conventional loans potentially more cost-effective for those with substantial savings. The absence of mortgage insurance not only lowers monthly payments but also increases long-term savings, appealing to financially strategic buyers.

In summary, while VA loans offer unique benefits for those eligible, a conventional loan can often be the better option for those investing in additional properties, aiming for cost savings through a large down payment, or simply not qualifying for VA benefits.”

Borrowers who can afford a sizeable down payment might prefer a conventional loan to avoid the VA funding fee and capitalize on the equity in their home from the outset. While VA loans are attractive due to no money down and the absence of monthly mortgage insurance, it’s important to consider the VA funding fee. This one-time, upfront charge can range from 1.25% to 3.3% of the loan amount, depending on your down payment and whether you’ve previously utilized a VA loan.

Key Considerations:

VA Funding Fee: This fee can significantly affect the overall cost of a VA loan, making it a crucial factor in your decision.
Down Payment Impact: With a conventional loan, putting down 20% or more can help you avoid PMI and the VA funding fee, potentially saving you money in the long run.
Overall Costs: Compare the total costs associated with both loan types to determine which is more financially advantageous for your situation.

Ultimately, while the VA funding fee might initially seem like a small detail, it plays a significant role in the financial comparison between a VA loan and a conventional loan.

Considerations when choosing conventional vs VA loans

Choosing the right loan type hinges on several factors, starting with your long-term financial objectives.

VA loans offer immediate benefits
Conventional loans might better suit those planning to invest in property or purchase vacation homes

Property type

Certain properties might not qualify for a VA loan, including:

Vacant land
Co-ops
Investment properties (at least one of the units must be a primary residence)
Vacation homes
Properties not accessible by a public or maintained private road
Tiny homes
Barndominiums
Manufactured home

All property types must meet the VA’s minimum property requirements—consult with your VA loan lender to see if a property you want might meet the requirements.

VA service eligibility

Lastly, your service eligibility for a VA loan is paramount—veterans and active service members exclusively access these loans.

Assess your eligibility before you consider a VA loan.

How to decide which loan is right for you

Start by assessing your financial readiness, including your savings for a down payment and your ability to cover monthly expenses. This foundational step ensures you understand your financial landscape before diving into specifics.
Consider your long-term housing plans and how they align with each loan type’s benefits and limitations. Are you planning to stay in the home for many years, or is it a stepping stone? Your plans can significantly impact which loan type suits you best.
Weigh the benefits of each type against your investment goals and the type of property you wish to purchase. Different loans cater to different property types and financial objectives, so aligning these factors is crucial.
Consult with a mortgage advisor to provide tailored insights. This includes visiting a loan officer who specializes in both VA and conventional loans. Meeting with a professional will help you compare mortgage rates and fees for both types of loans, given your specific financial details.
Crunch the numbers: This step is vital—analyzing the costs associated with each loan type can reveal which option aligns best with your budget and financial goals. Understanding the financial implications will empower you to make an informed choice.

How to Compare Mortgage Rates and Fees for VA and Conventional Loans

When deciding between VA and conventional loans, understanding the key differences in rates and fees is essential. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you navigate this process:

1. Gather Your Financial Information

Credit Score: Your credit score will influence the rates you’re offered, so know where you stand.
Income and Employment Details: Lenders will assess your ability to repay the loan based on your income and job stability.
Debt-to-Income Ratio: This ratio is crucial in determining your loan eligibility, impacting both VA and conventional loans.

2. Explore Reliable Online Resources

Use online tools to compare current mortgage rates. Websites like Bankrate and Zillow offer up-to-date rate listings, allowing you to see the differences between VA and conventional loans.
Consider using mortgage calculators available on these platforms. They help estimate monthly payments, including interest and fees, based on your financial situation.

3. Meet with a Loan Officer

Speak with a loan officer who specializes in both VA and conventional loans. They can provide personalized insights and help clarify any uncertainties.
Ask about any potential hidden fees and ensure you understand the total cost of each loan type.

4. Compare Fees and Benefits

VA Loans: Typically have lower interest rates and no down payment requirement for eligible veterans, but may include a funding fee.
Conventional Loans: May offer competitive rates for borrowers with excellent credit, but often require a down payment and private mortgage insurance (PMI) for high loan-to-value ratios.

5. Review the Loan Estimates

After identifying potential lenders, request loan estimates for both VA and conventional loans. These documents outline the interest rate, loan terms, fees, and monthly payments.
Compare these estimates side by side to see which offers the best value when considering your long-term financial goals.

By following these steps, you can confidently compare mortgage rates and fees for VA and conventional loans, ensuring you make an informed decision that aligns with your financial situation and homeownership goals.

Conventional vs VA loan: What’s the verdict?

If your decision comes down to a VA loan versus a conventional loan, your choice should be clearer now.

Each loan type offers distinct advantages tailored to specific financial situations, homeownership goals, and eligibility criteria.

Those key differences and advantages should equip you to make a choice that aligns with your long-term financial well-being and homeownership aspirations.

Remember, the decision is personal and varies significantly from one individual to another.

Learn more about your mortgage options by completing our simple form.

Our advise is based on experience in the mortgage industry and we are dedicated to helping you achieve your goal of owning a home. We may receive compensation from partner banks when you view mortgage rates listed on our website.